P.S. A Column On Things

By PAUL E. SCHINDLER JR. I am from Portland, Oregon, Beaumont ’66, Benson High ’70, MIT ’74. Some things are impossible to know, but it is impossible to know these things.

Never Saw His Face Plus LLM Putdowns Part 2

November 15, 2026

I Wrote A Song (for certain definitions of song) And You Can Too

Songs have lyrics, melody and (if you want anyone to hear them) performance. My skill lies in lyrics, so I outsource melody and performance to a remarkable Welsh performer I call the Welsh Wonder. Every song of mine is better because I picked a person with great talent to realize my lyrics with music and performance.

[Previously on PSACOT: I have written a “she done me wrong” song, Never Saw His Face. It is available on Spotify. You can get it without the link by asking for “Never Saw His Face by Paul Schindler.” It nestles among the two dozen songs I have written in the last six years, most of them love songs for my wife. Plus a few parodies and three anti-LLM parodies.]

Lyrics are just a poem (with a chorus) that is unlikely to be remembered easily. I could almost certainly not have memorized these odes to my wife (or parodies of power) if they were not set to music.

This gives me a chance to rag on LLM. I don’t know much about melody or performance (I have performed my music too; you be the judge). An LLM result is only as good as the prompt. If you just prompt “take these words, set them to music and sing them,” you’ll get a melody and performance that are statistically guaranteed to be the exact mean; not too good, not too bad.

In short: anodyne crap. GIGO; an LLM will never give you what you didn’t know you wanted in a piece of art (music = art). If you are an amateur, you’ll write an amateur prompt and get amateur results.

My collaborator is a human being. He has loved and lost. When he receives my lyrics, he sets them to an appropriate original tune, not a pastiche of every other tune to a song that uses a few similar words. He sets them to music appropriate to their meaning, not according to a statistical word count.

They say that what distinguished Frank Sinatra from other singers was that he sang the lyrics like he meant them. No LLM can sing lyrics that way; since it doesn’t know what they mean, it can’t sing them like it means them.

I am not saying the Welsh Wonder is Frank Sinatra, but he is a hell of a lot closer than the latest version of any LLM.

If you want to turn your lyrics into a real song, try The Welsh Wonder.

Posted at 9:15 pm Permalink No Comments

Comments

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Author's image

Paul E. Schindler Jr.

SEARCH PSACOT 2015-Present

Sign Up For Weekly Email Notification

* indicates required

Email Me

Email Me