P.S. A Column On Things

By PAUL E. SCHINDLER JR. I am from Portland, Oregon, Beaumont ’66, Benson High ’70, MIT ’74. Some things are impossible to know, but it is impossible to know these things.

Love Cycle and Quote Cycle

In the movie A Lonely Place (1950) Dixon Steele (Humphrey Bogart): “I was born when she kissed me. I died when she left me. I lived a few weeks while she loved me.” This was my experience a few times in life; I hope it was yours too. Better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all.

But…

Would we still remember this brilliant summary of love if Andrew P. Solt had said it at a party, or even before a full house at Carnegie Hall? No. Yet these are not Bogart’s words; he read them. Creation made the quotation possible; performance of them made them memorable.


Solt wrote them into a script, based on Edmund H. North’s adaptation of Dorothy B. Hughes’ 1947 novel.

And yet, there is more to the quote cycle than this. All of the dozens of Bogart quotes were written by someone else and performed by Bogart. Thus, the question that arises: do the words persist in (or even enter) the public mind by themselves? No. They gain notoriety through their performance. I doubt anyone would still be quoting Dorothy B. Hughes after 68 years.

I have experienced much the same thing. I wrote dozens of love poems for my wife. (With the help of others) I turned a couple of dozen of them into songs. Would I still remember the poem You Put My Heart on a Silver Plate five years after writing it? No, but I can recite it verbatim while singing it. Ear worms indeed. The difference between a poem and a song, among other things, is how much easier it is remember a song, and how much more likely it is that someone else will even sit still for the words.

I defy you to find 20 “civilians” — people who devote zero time pondering the wonders of show business—who don’t think that Elvis Presley wrote Hound Dog, and Frank Sinatra wrote That’s Life.  Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller (Hound Dog) and Dean Kay and Kelly Gordon (Life) might be saddened by this error, until the day each month when they (or their heirs) cash the royalty checks.

However, Taylor Swift writes all of her songs, and The Beatles (after covering the work of others early on) wrote all of theirs, so sometimes impressions are correct, as are attributions. Some singers credit the writers during public performances, but most don’t. It would be a nice habit.

Author's image

Paul E. Schindler Jr.

SEARCH PSACOT 2015-Present

Sign Up For Weekly Email Notification

* indicates required

Email Me

Email Me